Rachel Alexander, ESQ.
Child Custody Mediation
Alexander Mediation Group is a professional divorce mediation firm serving couples and families throughout New Jersey, New York City, and the Hamptons. Our mediator can help you work through your divorce's financial, emotional, and legal issues.
Rachel Alexander, ESQ.
Alexander Mediation Group
Rachel Alexander is a family law attorney and professional mediator specializing in family-related matters. For over 20 years, Rachel has handled various family law cases, including divorce, child custody, child support, prenuptial agreements, and more. Learn more about Rachel.
Creating a Child Custody and Joint Parenting Plan
Begin with the Needs of Your Children
Child custody mediation begins with the children rather than a preset schedule. Each child has a different age, personality, school routine, activity schedule, relationship with each parent, and response to change. A workable parenting plan accounts for those differences.
The discussion also considers the practical circumstances of both parents, including work schedules, travel, transportation, childcare, religious holidays, family traditions, and vacations. The goal is to create an arrangement that gives children reassurance and structure while allowing the family enough flexibility to respond when life changes.
This reflects Alexander Mediation’s broader approach to keeping children central to divorce decisions.
Understand Legal Custody and Residential Custody
New York and New Jersey distinguish between legal custody and residential custody. Legal custody concerns authority to make major decisions for the children, including decisions involving health, education, and general well-being. Residential custody concerns where the children primarily reside and how their time is divided between homes.
A joint custody agreement addresses both legal custody and residential custody. Joint legal custody generally means that both parents participate in major decisions, even when the children spend more time in one home. Joint residential custody means that the children divide substantial time between both parents’ homes.
Day-to-day decisions remain with the parent caring for the child at that time. The parenting plan can identify any specific decisions that require discussion and agreement so that both parents understand when their input and involvement are required.
Build a Consistent and Realistic Parenting Schedule
There is no single joint custody schedule that works for every family. Some parents alternate weeks. Others use shorter rotations or arrange the school week around one home. The best schedule is the one that reflects the children’s needs and the parents’ actual availability.
Consistency matters. A parent who promises more time than the reality of work, travel, or other responsibilities allows may unintentionally create disappointment and anxiety for the children. Mediation helps parents make a realistic assessment of their schedules and commit to an arrangement they can successfully maintain.
A clear, child-friendly calendar (i.e. a large, colorful, hung at their eye-level in a shared space) in both homes can help children envisage when they will see each parent. Predictability can be especially reassuring while the family adjusts to living across two households.
Plan for Holidays, School, Activities, and Time Apart
A parenting plan involves more than a weekly rotation. Parents also need to consider holidays, birthdays, school breaks, vacations, religious observances, extracurricular activities, transportation, and special family traditions.
Mediation gives parents room to work through these details before they become sources of conflict. It can also address how children will remain connected to the parent they are not staying with through regular phone and video calls Often parenting plans permit both parents to attend the children’s school plays, games and other important school and extracurricular events regardless of which parent has custody that day. This way the child can enjoy having both parents in attendance, unfettered by the custody schedule.
Supporting a child’s relationship with the other parent reinforces the presence and involvement of both parents. It nurtures the child’s experience of having a unified parental body upon which he can rely. It also helps children understand that they do not have to choose between the people they love.
Develop a Joint Approach to Parenting Decisions
Joint custody works best when parents can exchange information, discuss concerns, and solve problems respectfully. Mediation helps establish that working relationship by giving parents practice making decisions together during the divorce process.
Parents can identify how they will communicate about school, healthcare, activities, schedule changes, and other important matters. They can also decide how emergency situations will be handled and how the other parent will be informed after urgent needs have been addressed.
Custody arrangements are often connected to financial support for the children across two households. Once the parenting terms are settled, they can be memorialized in a Custody and Parenting Agreement, or incorporated into the appropriate written divorce agreement, which may be a separation agreement, property settlement agreement, marital settlement agreement, or stipulation of settlement.
Monthly Divorce Support Groups
A welcoming space for individuals navigating divorce, separation, or the contemplation of significant relationship change.
Child Custody and Joint Custody Mediation FAQ
What Does Joint Custody Mean?
Joint custody, also called joint legal custody refers to shared decision-making for significant matters concerning such things as the child’s health, medical interventions, religion and education. Joint residential custody means that children spend substantial time living with each parent.
The custody portion of any agreement should state clearly which responsibilities are shared, how decisions will be made, and how the children’s time will be divided.
Does Joint Custody Require Equal Parenting Time?
Not necessarily. Joint legal custody can exist even when the children live primarily, or exclusively, with one parent. Joint residential arrangements may also divide time substantially without dividing it equally.
Mediation focuses on what is practical for the parents and supportive for the children. School routines, work schedules, distance between homes, transportation, and the children’s individual needs may all affect the schedule.
How Do Parents Make Decisions with Joint Legal Custody?
Parents can refer to their custody agreement to identify which decisions require mutual input. These usually include significant matters involving education, healthcare, religious upbringing, and other issues fundamentally affecting the children’s well-being. In the event the parents disagree, the parent with whom the children reside more of the time will have the final word. If that is insufficient, when important issues arise, parents can always return to mediation to determine what best serves the child.
The parent caring for the child handles ordinary daily decisions affecting the child. In an emergency, the parent who is present is expected to respond posthaste when immediate action to protect the child is required, then contact the other parent as soon as possible so they can participate in the care and decisions that follow.
Will I Still Spend Holidays and Special Occasions with My Children?
A parenting plan can divide or alternate holidays, school breaks, birthdays, vacations, and other occasions that matter to the family. Parents may also preserve specific religious observances or family traditions. Parents can be as creative as they wish to ensure they see their children as much as possible during important times of the year. Some parents will divide a holiday annually, each taking a portion of the Thanksgiving break. Some parents will elect to spend certain holidays together with the children.
Mediation helps parents look at the entire year rather than only the regular weekly schedule. This makes it easier to identify potential conflicts and create a plan in which both parents have meaningful time with the children.
How Does Mediation Help Parents Reach a Custody Agreement?
Mediation gives parents a structured setting to determine priorities, discuss the children’s needs, and work through the practical details of parenting across two homes. Mediation helps parents discern what is already working and identify what needs to change.
The custody discussion can take place as part of the larger divorce mediation process. The resulting plan can address parenting time, joint decision-making, communication, holidays, activities, transportation, and any other issues to empower the family to move forward.
Subscribe to Our Monthly Newsletter
When navigating the unfamiliar terrain of divorce, it’s important to be accompanied by both fellow voyagers and expert guides.
By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Alexander Mediation Group, 37 Bay View Drive East, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United States. You can revoke your consent to receive marketing emails at any time using the SafeUnsubscribe® link found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact. Our Privacy Policy.
Child Custody Mediation Resources
50-50 parenting still requires 100% from both parents
Custody can be a loaded term, filled with implicit threats of loss — loss of control, loss of time, and loss of one’s children. Custody, both a legal and colloquial term, can render images of wailing children wrenched from the arms of panicking parents. One of my tasks as a mediator is to challenge antiquated, […]
What About the Pets?
What about the pets? It's not a foregone conclusion that separation or divorce means divorcing or forsaking your pet. That would be too heartbreaking for words, is avoidable, and is therefore unacceptable. Pets are a topic that folks often raise sheepishly, appreciating that when it comes to matrimonial law, divorce, and equitable distribution, animals are […]
Is This Marriage Viable & How to Evaluate
Couples’ counselor Meredith Keller explains how the willingness to discuss difficult relationship issues can help determine whether a marriage is viable. She also examines the important difference between an unwillingness to communicate and a lack of communication skills.
Are We as Modern as We Think? Gender Role Reversal in Divorce Doesn’t Necessarily Add Up
What happens when the father is the stay-at-home spouse and the mother is the primary earner? Can we simply swap out the term husband for wife and expect an equitable outcome? Let’s see. In cases where the mother is the stay-at-home parent and the father is the full-time working parent, the children typically reside with […]
Status Quo
to the best of your ability, keep on keeping on. Status quo has an important legal meaning for people going through a divorce. Status quo, meaning “the existing state of affairs,” informs divorcing parties what they are expected to do while they are in the process of divorcing. This interim time, the pendente lite period (pendency of […]
Don’t Weaponize the Children
In a recent divorce negotiation, a father raised several concerns about entering into a custody and parenting agreement for their nine-year-old son. His concerns are both legitimate and pertinent to most divorcing couples who are also parents of young children. Below are two of his concerns with my responses. Father’s Concern: “If I agree to […]
A Couple Walked Into a Marriage Counselor: The Problem & The Solution
Couples often struggle when one or both partners expect the other to manage their difficult emotions. Marriage counselor Meredith Keller explains how personal responsibility, space for both voices, and healthier communication can help couples respond more constructively.
The Good News About Infidelity – Parts 1 – 3
This article, part of the series with our partner and friend, couples therapist Meredith Keller, LPC, ACS, explores unfaithfulness and infidelity, challenging the misconception that they always necessitate the end of a marriage. While an affair usually signals marital issues requiring attention, infidelity need not necessitate divorce. There has long been the belief that divorce is the […]
Gottman: “Oh S^%&T, Your Marriage Is in Trou-ble”
In this article, we continue our series with colleague Meredith Keller, LPC, ACS, couples’ therapist, who explores with us the primary reasons couples come to her in the first place. Meredith identifies one of the primary issues in struggling marriages as this: one or both parties are unable to monitor – and moderate – their own […]
Preventing Trauma – A Guide
Because trauma is painful, complex, and difficult to resolve, what can we do to prevent it? How can we intervene in the place between hurt and harm? This is the space where we can make a difference. The healing is in the quality of listening. The power is in the relating. The same unhappy event […]